If you’ve been following along on my Instagram, you already got a few sneak peeks of this big project we’ve had going on behind the scenes. Well… it’s finally time for the official reveal. We just had our old roof replaced with gorgeous designer shingles, and we are completely smitten with how it turned out!
What started as a stressful surprise from Hurricane Helene turned into a blessing in disguise.
Thanks to our insurance company covering most of the cost, we were able to upgrade our roof in a way that seriously upped our home’s curb appeal—and longevity too. We did a ton of research and pulled together all of the info so you don’t have to, if it’s on your home improvement list.
Architectural Shingles vs Designer Shingles
Here is what our roof looked like before… these were architectural shingles, which were already an upgrade from standard 3-tab shingles, but designer ones were an even bigger upgrade.
Architectural shingles offer a durable, dimensional look at a moderate price (about $5.50 to $12.25 per square foot), while designer shingles provide a thicker, more detailed, high-end appearance that mimics premium materials like slate or cedar at a higher cost (about $12.50 to $15.50 per square foot).
Related: FAQs About Our Limewashed Brick House
Why We Chose Designer Roof Shingles
When we found out our roof needed to be replaced, we figured—if we’re already going through the hassle, why not go all in and choose something we really want?
I didn’t know much about shingle options out there, just that there were definitely better looking ones than what we already had. That’s when we stumbled into the world of designer shingles.
These aren’t your basic builder-grade 3-tab shingles. Designer shingles are made to mimic the look of high-end materials like slate or cedar shake, and they bring so much texture, depth, and character to a roof.
We chose CertainTeed Belmont luxury shingles in the color Colonial Slate.
Ours have that classic, timeless look with a subtle variation in tone that adds instant charm. It’s the kind of detail you don’t always notice right away… until you do. And then you can’t unsee it—in the best way.
Related: Our Colonial Front Door Replacement
Related: 6 Ways to Add Instant Curb Appeal
What Makes Designer Shingles Different?
Here’s how designer shingles stack up against standard ones:
✨ Pros of Designer Shingles
- Better curb appeal: They’re styled to look like upscale roofing materials but without the sky-high price tag of slate or wood.
- More durable: They’re thicker and heavier, which means they hold up better in high winds and harsh weather (huge for us, in an area that experiences hurricanes often).
- Longer lifespan: Depending on the brand and installation, they can last 30 years to 50 years or more.
- More color and style options: Whether your home leans traditional, modern, or anything in between, there’s likely a designer shingle style that fits.
🤔 Cons to Consider
- Higher upfront cost: Compared to basic shingles, these come with a premium price—although ours was mostly covered by insurance (hallelujah).
- Heavier weight: Because of their thickness, they’re heavier on your roof structure. Most homes can handle them just fine, but it’s something to verify with your roofer.
- Not all brands are created equal: Like anything, you’ll want to make sure you’re choosing a reputable brand with solid warranties. We researched many roofing companies in our area until we found one that we definitely trusted (Taylor Roofing is the roofing contractor we chose if you’re in the Charlotte area). They were able to recommend the designer shingle brand CertainTeed Belmont.
Related: Front Yard Makeover – How We Revived Our Lawn in a Year
Are Designer Shingles Worth It?
Short answer: YES.
Long answer: still yes, especially if you’re looking for a roof that’s not only built to last but also enhances your home’s exterior in a big way. It’s one of those costs that will eventually come back to you in resale since they significantly increase a home’s value. (Although, we don’t have plans to sell our house any time soon.)
This isn’t one of those upgrades that you only appreciate from the inside. It’s a curb appeal game-changer. Every time I glance up at our roof, I get a little flutter of happiness. It looks just like a slate roof.
I know… they’re just shingles. But it’s one of those little details that makes your home feel more you. It just fits.
I love how the new shingles tie in with our limewashed brick, shutters, new front door, flower beds, and lawn facelift in a way that makes the whole house feel more pulled together.
We eventually need to replace our old gutters too, but that’s a project for a different day. I love the idea of copper gutters… it’s just a matter of deciding if those are worth the higher price tag.
We’re beyond happy with how our roof turned out, and I hope this gives you some helpful info if you’re ever faced with the same decision.
More Curb Appeal Resources
